We can help you buy or sell a residential or commercial property anywhere in Australia. Leasing contract services included.
ForumLaw provides legal services and contract work for any type of business transaction from business registration to succession matters.
We'll help make your project a success, from setting up & revising contracts and agreements to tracking sales & leases in multiple-strata unit projects online!
Choose a package that suits your needs. We then maintain constant legal watch of your business.
Take control of your assets today. Contact ForumLaw to arrange a new Will or review any existing arragements in place.
Stay in touch with how the law affects you! Subscribe to our
Regal Consulting Services Pty Ltd v All Seasons Air Pty Ltd  NSWSC 613
In March we covered a case where the absence of a "reference date" in the contract resulted in a finding against the plaintiff claimant. A “reference date” under s.8(2) of the Building & Construction Industry Security of Payments Act NSW is a date determined by or in accordance with the contract as at which the date that a progress claim may be made, or if there is no such date in the contract, it’s the last of the named month in which the construction work was first carried out and the last date of each subsequent named month.
The Supreme Court in this recent case found in favour of the plaintiff, Regal Consulting Services Pty Ltd (“Regal”) in relation to the “reference dates” for payment claims under a construction contract.
On 8 July 2015 Regal entered into a subcontract with All Seasons Air Pty Ltd (“All Seasons”) for construction works. Under this contract, progress claims were able to be served on the 20th day of each month. The contract also provided that payment claims made prior to the 20th day of any month “shall be deemed to have been made on the date for making that claim”.
On 12 July 2016 All Seasons served a progress claim on Regal; Regal served All Seasons with a payment schedule disputing payment for the entire payment claim. Regal’s position in their payment schedule was that there was no suitable reference date in All Seasons’ payment claim because they had already served a payment claim for the reference date on 20 June 2016, and the next reference date on 20 July 2016 had not yet accrued.
All Seasons' payment claim was referred to an adjudicator who concluded that she had jurisdiction to deal with the dispute and that the adjudicated amount was the claimed amount. All Seasons obtained an adjudication certificate which they filed in the local court to obtain a judgment debt for the amount claimed.
Regal then brought proceedings in the Supreme Court against All Seasons and the adjudicator. Regal disputed that they owed the amount claimed and also disputed that the adjudicator had jurisdiction to deal with the dispute, due to the lack of an available reference date to support the payment claim.
The main issues for the court to determine in this case were:
The Court found that there was no available reference date supporting the progress claim, and found in Regal’s favour.
This case is a fresh reminder for people in the building and construction industry that the reference date for issuing a payment claim under a contract must be clearly expressed and not leave any room for confusion or other interpretation which may develop into expensive and time-wasting litigation.
The reference date is critical to ensure that the payment claim is valid.